Stahl York Avenue Co. LLC

Corporate Owner

•

Head Officer

•

Officer

•

21 Properties

•

1252 Units

•

4.2(12)

Evictions: 32

Litigation History: Yes

Review Summary for Stahl York Avenue Co. LLC

Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.

Residents of buildings managed by STAHL YORK AVENUE CO. LLC generally find the properties clean with efficient garbage management and good heating. Maintenance staff are typically responsive and attentive, contributing to a well-kept living environment. Tenants appreciate quiet neighbors and security, though some note noise issues due to street and nearby freeway traffic. Concerns include occasional pest problems, sporadic maintenance delays, and construction noise. Some units are spacious but may lack natural light. A few complaints highlight unaddressed abandoned units leading to pest infestations. Overall, the management is seen as responsive and maintaining affordable, decent-quality housing on the Upper East Side.

Open Violations

Only open violations from the last 10 years.

Data last updated 7 days ago.

The average number of violations per unit for this owner/associates across their portfolio is better than the city.

BUILDING AVERAGE:

0.03 violations per unit

NEW YORK CITY AVERAGE:

0.81 violation per unit

Non-hazardous

class A

i.e. no peephole on a door, or no street # on the building, unlawful keeping of animals

MOST RECENT:

Mar 16, 2016: § 27-2005 adm code refit door in the bathroom located at apt 6p, 6th story, 1st apartment from east at south

Show all

Hazardous

class B

i.e. smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways

MOST RECENT:

Jan 28, 2018: § 27-2005 adm code repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color the ceilings and all walls through-out in the entire apartment located at apt 6p, 6th story, 1st apartment from east at south

Show all

Immediately hazardous

class C

i.e. rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts

MOST RECENT:

Jul 16, 2021: § 27-2056.6 adm code - correct the lead-based paint hazard - paint that tested positive for lead content and that is peeling or on a deteriorated subsurface - using work practices set forth in 28 rcny §11-06(b)(2) north wall in the private hallway located at apt 2d, 2nd story, 2nd apartment from north at east

Show all

Missing information/filings

class I

Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings

MOST RECENT:

Nov 17, 2025: §27-2107 adm code owner failed to file a valid registration statement with the department as required by adm code §27-2097 and is therefore subject to civil penalties, prohibited from certifying violations, and denied the right to recover possession of premises for nonpayment of rent until a valid registration statement is filed.

Show all

All Properties Associated with Stahl York Avenue Co. LLC

Downtown Brooklyn

392 Bridge Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Units • Floors

0(0)

Rent Stabilized Units: Yes

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: No

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Lenox Hill

517 East 71 Street, Manhattan, NY 10021

126 Units • 13 Floors

0(0)

Rent Stabilized Units: Unknown

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: No

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Lenox Hill

429 East 64 Street, Manhattan, NY 10065

95 Units • 6 Floors

0(0)

Rent Stabilized Units: Unknown

Good Cause Eviction: Yes

Evictions: 1

Litigation History: Yes

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Lenox Hill

430 East 65 Street, Manhattan, NY 10065

95 Units • 6 Floors

0(0)

Rent Stabilized Units: Yes

Good Cause Eviction: Yes

Evictions: 1

Litigation History: Yes

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Reviews (12)

2 days ago

Great Place to live!

Former Tenant

Pros:

The staff is great, there are a lot of maintenance workers so things do not get left to pile up, etc...

Cons:

sometimes construction in the building is loud

Advice to owner:

keep up the great work

3 months ago

Old building with some renovated units, fine for 1 person

Former Tenant

Pros:

quiet street, responsive management who addresses problems properly

Cons:

renovated but some renovations were done hastily/cheaply

4 months ago

You get what you pay for…

Former Tenant

Pros:

Neighbors are nice

Cons:

So, so loud

5 months ago

Affordable walkup near the east river

Former Tenant

Pros:

Affordable, clean, peaceful and quiet

Cons:

Walkup, not much natural light in some of the rooms. Laundry is in the basement outside.

5 months ago

Nice but basic

Former Tenant

Pros:

Quiet neighbors, maintenance issues are usually promptly tended to, good security.

Cons:

None really. It is basic housing but far from luxury

7 months ago

8/10 New York Building. But outside of NYC? would be a 5/10 Building

Former Tenant

Pros:

Building is well kept for the most part, and has an elevator - which is uncommon on this street. The intercom functions, they have weekly pest control available. shared spaces are clean & building is quiet & friendly. Some of the staff is great!

Cons:

apartments with deceased tenants are left UNTOUCHED (ex. the food in their fridge) for YEARS. Like im talking the police tape is still over the door, several years later. Bugs are crawling out of the doorway and they refuse to do anything about it. Packages get stolen and some of the staff is quite rude. attached "Leasing Office" also seems to have nothing to do with leases & cannot answer simple questions about rent.

Advice to owner:

clean up dead peoples apartments and dont let them sit for literal years causing roach infestations.

8 months ago

NYC Apt in a nice area on the UES!

Former Tenant

Pros:

Building kept clean

Cons:

Sometimes on the 1st floor being close to the street can be noisy but that comes with living in NYC.

Advice to owner:

None that I can think of.

Over 1 year ago

Okay apartment in UES

Former Tenant

Pros:

Apartment was clean for NYC, managment was responsive to complaints, neighbors and neighborhood were relatively quiet

Cons:

mouse problem (well miditgated by leasing office), package theives

Over 1 year ago

Nice place to live

Former Tenant

Pros:

Nice building, the management took things seriously. The were goodwill

Cons:

Poor response for repair and maintenance of the building was not great

Advice to owner:

None

Over 1 year ago

Extremely loud next to the freeway exit

Former Tenant

Pros:

This is a nice apartment. The apartment is also more spacious than most in the UES area. Rent is reasonable.

Cons:

If you are in the bedroom facing the street, it is extremely loud. All of the cars that exit off the FDR exit and turn onto 64th st. The windows are now soundproof; and in the summer with a window AC, you're out of luck. You'll need to get used to earplugs.

Over 2 years ago

Great Rent Stable Apartment

Former Tenant

Pros:

Love the location, price and space

Cons:

A bit dark in apartments

Over 4 years ago

Overall a good place to live

Former Tenant

Pros:

Friendly and responsive super, nice neighbors, fairly well maintained building

Cons:

Ongoing construction creates noise but it was getting steadily better