NYC Buildings
/
Manhattan
/
Midtown East
/
Sutton Place
/
238 East 58 Street
Sutton Place

238 East 58 Street,
Manhattan, NY 10022

22 Units

•

Built in 1904

•

6 Floors

2.8(1)
Rent Stabilized Units: Yes
Good Cause Eviction: Yes
Evictions: 2
Litigation History: Yes
1 Year Bedbug History: No
Pet Friendly: Unknown
Building Overview
Building Report
    Do you own or manage this building?
    Hey smart renter!
    In the past three years, this building had:
    33 complaints
    Get building reports for more information
    You Will Get:
    call-center
    Building complaint and pricing history broken down by month.
    rat
    The latest rodent inspection reports.
    construction
    Existing or upcoming construction projects in the building and area.
    And more...
    Open Violations
    A violation is issued to a building when a city inspector from NYC's Department of Housing Preservation and Development validates and confirms a complaint made to 311. The violations listed below are open violations that have yet to be addressed or have not been confirmed as resolved by the city.
    Only open violations from the last 10 years.
    Data last updated 2 days ago.
    BUILDING AVERAGE:
    0.5 violations per unit
    NEW YORK CITY AVERAGE:
    0.81 violation per unit
    flag
    Non-hazardous
    2
    class A
    i.e. no peephole on a door, or no street # on the building, unlawful keeping of animals
    MOST RECENT:
    Oct 23, 2024: § 329, m/d law and dept. rules and regs. provide a completed certificate of inspection visits in a proper frame at or near mailboxes, bottom edge of frame between 48-62 inches above floor missing frame at public hall, 1st story
    Show all
    flag
    Hazardous
    1
    class B
    i.e. smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways
    MOST RECENT:
    Oct 18, 2023: § 27-2010, 2011, 2012 adm code remove the accumulation of refuse and/or rubbish and maintain in a clean condition the east court
    Show all
    flag
    Immediately hazardous
    8
    class C
    i.e. rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts
    MOST RECENT:
    Oct 23, 2024: § 27-2005 adm code & 309 m/d law abate the nuisance consisting of fridge with door attched at public hall, 1st story
    Show all
    flag
    Missing information/filings
    0
    class I
    Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings
    MOST RECENT:
    No violation found...
    Show all
    Property Owners and Associates
    R
    Ramiel Ben Yehuda
    2.9(18)
    Site Manager•
    Head Officer•
    6 Properties•111 Units
    Litigation History: Yes
    Evictions: 5
    B
    Brighton Management
    3(58)
    Agent•
    34 Properties•521 Units
    Litigation History: Yes
    Evictions: 22
    logo
    Eileen Shields
    4(245)
    Corporate Owner•
    521 Properties•38413 Units
    Litigation History: Yes
    Evictions: 112
    E
    238 East 58th Partners LLC
    2.8(1)
    Corporate Owner•
    2 Properties•69 Units
    Litigation History: Yes
    Evictions: 2
    Frequently Asked Questions

    Renter Q&A

    ask-question
    Be the first to ask a question!

    Building Ratings

    Cleanliness
    1 (unmanaged) to 5 (well managed)
    Garbage Management
    1 (poorly managed) to 5 (well organized)
    Heat
    1 (faulty) to 5 (working)
    Neighbors
    1 (loud / disrespectful) to 5 (friendly and considerate)
    Noise Levels
    1 (loud) to 5 (quiet)
    Owner Responsiveness
    1 (slow) to 5 (timely)
    Pest Control
    1 (lots of pests) to 5 (no pests)
    Water Pressure
    1 (weak) to 5 (strong)
    Cleanliness
    Garbage Management
    Heat
    Neighbors
    Noise Levels
    Owner Responsiveness
    Pest Control
    Water Pressure

    Renter Recommendations

    --% of renters recommend this building

    --% of renters approve of this owner

    Rents and Deposits

    -- of renters received their security deposits back
    It HAS NOT been reported if this building accepts electronic rent payments.

    Reviews (1)

    Over 2 years ago
    238 E 58th
    Former Tenant
    Pros:
    Updated kitchen. Priscilla is great. Neighbors have been there a while so very friendly. Feels like a community.

    Know the law: if they do not return your SD in 14 days, you get a full refund.
    Cons:
    Constant construction in first floor for commercial tenants that never move in and are never done working.

    The club in the side of the building is ridiculously loud at night, every night.

    ZERO AMENITIES. you get nothing but the bare minimum and very little space. Bathroom is TINY. Zero control of heat and no AC unless you have a unit in the window.

    Bugs and rats are constant! It’s disgusting.
    Advice to owner:
    Better pest control.