Pros:
Large rooms, lofted beds create nice extra space, large and well appointed living spaces with plenty of space, great kitchen space for NYC, modern bathrooms, amazing rooftop which is perfect for the New York summer, relatively quiet street, a stones throw from the park! Great neighbourhood. Nice apartment building atmosphere, very relaxed.
Cons:
This landlord is bad news, heating and water system failed at least eight times over the course of one winter and they refused to invest in finding a permanent solution, landlord would enter apartments without warning nor thorough reasoning, we always felt like we were being monitored in our own apartment, the rooms were overpriced at the time, landlord kept my deposit and other’s who have since left the building (his response to me when I left and requested my deposit was that he was ‘NOT AN ATM’), landlord was not timely in responding to issues. We also became aware that the building owner was in prison for property and landlord offences and that we were paying rent to his brother who was masquerading as him! The building is also relatively far away from a bigger supermarket, laundromat (no onsite laundry) and the local trains. Poorly built apartments, ie. thin roof, you can hear everything upstairs, cheap kitchen fixtures, etc.
Advice to owner:
You need to be more transparent and honest with your renters, particularly when deposits and fees are paid in good faith. Honestly, the landlord situation made living there not worth the hassle. I personally think the management were taking advantage of a certain type of renter and approved people who were renting in New York for the first time, mostly foreigners and students who were more naïve to the way the rental market works in New York. Contracts were ignored and this is frankly against the law.